Caleb joined CIY as an intern in 2014, and met his wife, Alexis, through that experience. In May 2017, he graduated from Ozark Christian College and got married that following November. Both Caleb and Alexis are from Oklahoma City. Caleb is a MOVE program coordinator for CIY, and Alexis works for Limelight Marketing in Pittsburg, Kansas. They make their home together in Joplin, Missouri.